Are Three-Minute Songs Bad For Music?
Curated from: Ted Gioia
Ideas, facts & insights covering these topics:
6 ideas
·470 reads
6
Explore the World's Best Ideas
Join today and uncover 100+ curated journeys from 50+ topics. Unlock access to our mobile app with extensive features.
Historical Context: Music as Ritual and Trance
- Music has ancient roots in ritual and trance, serving as a tool to induce altered mind states.
- Ancient practices like Ptolemy's experiments with visual rhythm and observations of animal behavior demonstrate humanity's inherent connection to rhythmic stimuli.
- Ritualistic musical experiences typically require around 10 minutes to induce trance-like states, a phenomenon observed across cultures.
12
93 reads
Physiological Benefits of Music
- Research by Dr. Barry Bitman highlights the health benefits of musical engagement, particularly drumming.
- Playing drums for at least 10 minutes can lead to physiological changes, such as altered blood cell counts and increased antibody release.
- Longer musical engagements correlate with greater health benefits, suggesting a minimum duration for reaping these rewards.
12
82 reads
Historical Regulation and Government Intervention
- Throughout history, governments have regulated musical rituals due to concerns over public safety and behavior, such as the Roman Senate's prohibition of Bacchanalia (circa 186 AD).
- This historical precedent underscores the recognition of music's power to influence behavior and alter consciousness.
11
80 reads
Constraints of Traditional Music Formats
- The traditional three-minute song format originated from early recording limitations, not physiological or regulatory concerns.
- Despite advancements in technology, the cultural preference for short musical performances persists, limiting opportunities for extended musical experiences â altered mind states and a sense of ecstasy and euphoria.
11
74 reads
The Push for Longer Musical Forms
- Visionary musicians like John Coltrane and innovative bands of the late 1960s challenged the constraints of traditional song lengths.
- Extended musical compositions offer opportunities for deeper engagement, hypnotic effects, and altered perceptions of reality.
- Embracing longer song forms can enrich musical experiences, transcending entertainment to tap into music's transformative potential.
13
68 reads
IDEAS CURATED BY
Content Curator | Absurdist | Amateur Gamer | Failed musician | Successful pessimist | Pianist |
CURATOR'S NOTE
In this series of unscripted videos, Ted explores whether the three-minute pop song hurts music. Let's dive in!
â
Read & Learn
20x Faster
without
deepstash
with
deepstash
with
deepstash
Personalized microlearning
â
100+ Learning Journeys
â
Access to 200,000+ ideas
â
Access to the mobile app
â
Unlimited idea saving
â
â
Unlimited history
â
â
Unlimited listening to ideas
â
â
Downloading & offline access
â
â
Supercharge your mind with one idea per day
Enter your email and spend 1 minute every day to learn something new.
I agree to receive email updates